Market Lead

Alluring Kitchens

Comprehensive PPC Performance Audit — V2
Report Date: 10 February 2026
Period: Last 30 Days (11 Jan – 9 Feb)
Data Sources: Google Ads API • Meta Graph API • GA4
Google Ads: 868-674-2615
Meta Ads: act_1493060414821811
GA4 Property: 375433850
Account Health Score
65
out of 100
Campaign Structure (Google)
7/10
Campaign Structure (Meta)
8/10
Quality Score
4/10
Creative Performance
7/10
Search Term Relevance
6/10
Audience & Demographics
7/10
Ad Copy & RSAs
6/10
Conversion Tracking
7/10
Budget & Bidding
6/10
Website / Landing Pages
3/10
Cross-Platform Strategy
6/10
YouTube / Video
2/10
Score breakdown: Green (7-10) = Healthy. Amber (5-6) = Needs attention. Red (1-4) = Critical. Scoring based on industry benchmarks for kitchen renovation / home improvement.
Cross-Platform Dashboard
$7,892
Total Ad Spend
224
Total Leads
$35.23
Blended CPL
4,435
Total Sessions (GA4)
71.3%
Avg Bounce Rate

Spend & Lead Split

Google Ads
$1,651
42 leads
Meta Ads
$6,241
182 leads

GA4 Traffic by Channel

Paid Social
2,835
87.7% bounce
Organic Search
724
39.0% bounce
Paid Search
357
45.9% bounce
Direct
250
58.4% bounce
Organic Social
235
57.9% bounce
Google Analytics 4 — Website Health
Critical Finding: Paid Social (Meta Ads) drives 65% of all sessions but has 87.7% bounce rate and only 12.3% engagement rate. Users spend just 21 seconds on average. This suggests the landing page experience for Meta traffic is fundamentally broken.

Channel Quality Comparison

ChannelSessionsUsersPageviewsBounce RateAvg DurationEngagementQuality
Organic Search 724 485 1,545 39.0% 2m 47s 61.0% Excellent
Referral 13 13 27 23.1% 2m 33s 76.9% Excellent
Paid Search (Google Ads) 357 301 505 45.9% 2m 01s 54.1% Good
Direct 250 229 376 58.4% 1m 10s 41.6% Fair
Organic Social 235 215 357 57.9% 49s 42.1% Fair
Paid Video (YouTube) 13 11 14 76.9% 22s 23.1% Poor
Paid Social (Meta Ads) 2,835 2,607 3,288 87.7% 21s 12.3% Critical

Landing Page Quality (GA4)

Landing PageSessionsBounce RateAvg DurationEngagementQuality
/outdoor-kitchen 2,244 90.6% 14.8s 9.4% Critical
/ (homepage) 1,643 57.8% 1m 40s 42.2% Fair
/gallery 56 41.1% 1m 44s 58.9% Good
/timber-kitchen-benchtops 36 38.9% 3m 08s 61.1% Excellent
/outdoor-kitchens-adelaide 21 14.3% 2m 47s 85.7% Excellent
/kitchen-renovations-in-adelaide 19 94.7% 7s 5.3% Critical
/thank-you (confirmation) 53 30.2% 24s 69.8% Expected
Landing Page Crisis: The /outdoor-kitchen page receives 2,244 sessions (51% of all traffic) but has a 90.6% bounce rate and users leave after just 14.8 seconds. This is where $4,167 of Meta outdoor kitchen ad spend sends traffic. Improving this single page could transform the account's ROI.
What works: The /outdoor-kitchens-adelaide page (organic) has 85.7% engagement rate and 2m 47s duration. Compare its content/layout to the underperforming /outdoor-kitchen landing page to identify what's different.

GA4 Daily Sessions Trend (30 Days)

Jan 11Jan 18Jan 25Feb 1Feb 9
Google Ads Analysis
$1,651
Spend
22,884
Impressions
371
Clicks
1.62%
CTR
$4.45
Avg CPC
42
Conversions
$39.31
CPA

Campaign Performance

CampaignTypeStrategySpendClicksCTRCPCConvCPAImpr ShareStatus
Brand Search Max Conv $465 169 19.61% $2.75 24 $19.38 - Best
Renovation [Location KW] Search tCPA $540 77 8.40% $7.01 7 $77.15 - Review
Renovation [Broad Test] Search tCPA $260 63 5.12% $4.13 9 $28.90 - Good
Renovation [Generic] Search tCPA $151 23 6.61% $6.56 2 $75.40 - Review
YouTube Retargeting (Outdoor) YouTube Max Value $165 31 0.20% $5.33 0 - - Waste
YouTube Retargeting (Kitchen) YouTube Manual CPC $39 7 0.29% $5.59 0 - - Waste
YouTube Prospecting YouTube Manual CPC $30 1 0.05% $30.49 0 - - Waste

Quality Score Analysis

KeywordQSCTRRelevanceLanding
alluring kitchens8GoodGoodGood
kitchen renovations adelaide4AvgAvgAvg
kitchen renovators4AvgAvgAvg
kitchen renovation adelaide2BelowBelowBelow

CPC Impact Calculator

Current avg CPC (non-brand):$5.86
Est. CPC at QS 7:$3.50 (-40%)
Monthly CPC savings:~$280/mo
Or: additional clicks at same budget:+80 clicks

Landing Page Performance (Google Ads)

URLClicksCTRCostConvCPAGA4 BounceGA4 DurationHealth
go.alluringkitchens.com.au/ 320 3.52% $1,429 35 $40.84 57.8% 1m 40s Fair
go.alluringkitchens.com.au/outdoor-kitchen 25 0.16% $164 0 - 90.6% 14.8s Critical

Device Performance

DeviceSpendClicksConvCPAConv ShareAction
Mobile$1,08628733$32.9179%Scale
Desktop$491749$54.5721%Monitor
Tablet$74100-0%Exclude

Conversion Tracking Health

ActionTypeStatusCategory
Lead SubmissionFormActiveLead
Dynamic Call TrackingCallActiveCall
Calls from adsCallActiveCall
Quote GivenCustomActiveOffline
GA4 (web) purchasePurchasePAUSEDPurchase
Meta Ads Analysis
$6,241
Spend
182
Leads
$34.29
CPL
1.18%
CTR
$10.42
CPM
87.7%
GA4 Bounce Rate

Campaign Performance

CampaignSpendLeadsCPLCTRStatus
Outdoor Kitchen - Prospecting [Broad]$4,167100$41.671.12%Volume
Kitchen Renovations - Prospecting [Broad]$1,24546$27.071.13%Best CPL
Kitchen Renovations - Prospecting$45623$19.84-Efficient
Kitchen Renovations - Retargeting$27410$27.38-Good
Outdoor Kitchen - Retargeting$983$32.73-Good

Audience / Ad Set Performance

TargetingCampaignSpendLeadsCPLRating
Interest - Kitchen CabinetKitchen Reno$17910$17.92Top Performer
LLA - All Website TrafficKitchen Reno$23811$21.61Scale
BroadKitchen Reno$1,24546$27.07Efficient
RetargetingKitchen Reno$27410$27.38Good
BroadOutdoor Kitchen$4,167100$41.67High Volume

Placement Performance

Facebook Feed
94 leads
$32.17 CPL
Marketplace
27 leads
$25.11 CPL
IG Feed
21 leads
$44.07 CPL
IG Stories
14 leads
$35.65 CPL
IG Reels
6 leads
$69.82 CPL

Demographics Performance

SegmentSpendLeadsCPLRating
55-64 Female$61524$25.64Best
65+ Female$45417$26.68Scale
35-44 Male$1,07434$31.60Good
45-54 Female$1,05030$35.02Good
35-44 Female$1,26132$39.40Average
45-54 Male$63115$42.08Average
25-34 Female$4237$60.41Costly
Sweet Spot: Women 55+
55-64 and 65+ females deliver $25-27 CPL but only receive 17% of budget. These are likely empty nesters / retirees renovating. Scale this segment.
Costly: 25-34 Age Group
$60.41 CPL for 25-34 females — 2.4x the best segment. This demographic likely can't afford kitchen renovations. Consider excluding or capping.

Device Performance (Meta)

DeviceSpendClicksLeadsShare
Mobile App$5,6625,69215397%
Desktop$145--2%
Mobile Web$84--1%
Step-by-Step Action Plan
1

Fix the /outdoor-kitchen Landing Page Critical

Problem: 90.6% bounce rate, 14.8s avg duration, 9.4% engagement. This page receives $4,167/mo in Meta spend (67% of Meta budget) and 2,244 monthly sessions.

  1. Compare with /outdoor-kitchens-adelaide — this organic page has 85.7% engagement and 2m47s duration. Identify what content, layout, and social proof differences exist.
  2. Check page load speed — run PageSpeed Insights. If mobile load >3 seconds, this alone explains high bounce.
  3. Add above-the-fold content — hero image, clear headline ("Outdoor Kitchens Adelaide"), social proof (reviews), and CTA must be visible without scrolling.
  4. Add gallery/portfolio — the /gallery page has 58.9% engagement. Showcasing real projects keeps users on page longer.
  5. Test instant form vs landing page — if bounce stays high, test using Meta's native Instant Forms instead of sending traffic to the website.
Est. Impact: Reducing bounce from 90% to 60% could 2-3x conversion rate, generating 30-50 additional leads/month
2

Pause YouTube Campaigns Critical

Problem: 3 YouTube campaigns spent $235 with zero conversions. GA4 confirms Paid Video has 76.9% bounce rate and 22s duration.

  1. Pause all 3 YouTube campaigns immediately in Google Ads (Outdoor YT Retargeting, Kitchen YT Retargeting, Kitchen YT Prospecting).
  2. Reallocate the $235/mo budget to the Broad Match Test campaign (currently delivering $28.90 CPA) or increase Brand campaign budget.
  3. If retesting YouTube later: use video assets that have worked on Meta (Outdoor Kitchen videos), target custom intent audiences (people searching for kitchen renovations), and measure view-through conversions over 30+ days before judging.
Est. Impact: Save $235/month or generate ~6-8 additional Search leads
3

Improve Quality Scores (2-4 → 7+) High Priority

Problem: Non-brand keywords at QS 2-4 means Google is charging 50-100% premium on CPCs.

  1. Ad Relevance: Create tighter ad groups with dedicated RSAs per keyword theme. "kitchen renovations adelaide" should have an RSA with that exact phrase in Headline 1 (pinned).
  2. Landing Page Experience: Create keyword-specific landing page variants or dynamic content sections matching search intent. The /kitchen-renovations-in-adelaide page has 94.7% bounce — it needs a complete rebuild.
  3. Expected CTR: Test new RSA headlines focused on unique selling points (free brochure, Adelaide-specific, gallery of work). Use at least 12 headlines and 4 descriptions per RSA.
  4. Monitor QS weekly using the Google Ads interface keyword report. Target QS 7+ within 60 days.
Est. Impact: Reduce CPC by 30-50% (~$280/mo savings) and improve ad position
4

Re-enable GA4 Purchase Conversion Medium

Problem: GA4 purchase conversion action is paused, removing conversion value signals from Smart Bidding.

  1. Check if this action was paused intentionally — if it was tracking e-commerce purchases on a non-e-commerce site, it may have been paused correctly.
  2. If applicable, re-enable in Google Ads > Goals > Conversions > "Alluring Kitchens - GA4 (web) purchase" > change status to Active.
  3. If not applicable (no e-commerce), consider adding conversion values to the Lead Submission action ($500-1000 default value based on avg kitchen renovation value).
Est. Impact: Better Smart Bidding signals, improved tCPA/tROAS optimization
5

Reduce IG Reels & Scale Marketplace Medium

Problem: IG Reels CPL is $69.82 (2x average). Marketplace CPL is $25.11 (best placement).

  1. In Meta Ads Manager, go to ad set level > Placements > switch from Advantage+ to Manual Placements.
  2. Exclude Instagram Reels from the Outdoor Kitchen Prospecting campaign (highest spend).
  3. Monitor Marketplace performance — it's delivering $25.11 CPL and has room to scale.
  4. Keep Facebook Feed as primary ($32.17 CPL, 94 leads, 52% of all leads).
Est. Impact: Reallocating IG Reels $419 to better placements = 12-16 additional leads
6

Scale 55+ Female & LLA Audiences Medium

Problem: Best CPL segments (55+ women at $25-27 and LLAs at $21.61) receive disproportionately low budget.

  1. Create a dedicated ad set targeting women 55-65+ with Kitchen Cabinet interest. Use creative that resonates with empty nesters (e.g., "Finally renovate the kitchen you've always wanted").
  2. Build new LLA audiences from lead form submissions (1%, 2%, 3% LLAs). The current All Website Traffic LLA at $21.61 CPL proves the concept.
  3. Reduce 25-34 age bid by applying a -30% bid adjustment or excluding entirely. Current $60.41 CPL is 2.4x the best segment.
Est. Impact: 15-20% overall CPL reduction by shifting budget to proven segments
7

Exclude Tablet Devices on Google Ads Quick Win

Problem: Tablet spent $74 with zero conversions.

  1. In Google Ads, go to each campaign > Devices tab > set Tablet bid adjustment to -100%.
  2. Apply across all active Search campaigns.
Est. Impact: Save $74/month immediately, redirect to mobile (79% of conversions)
8

Increase Video Creative Budget on Meta Optimization

Problem: Video ads deliver 2.3-3.2% CTR and $19.84 CPL vs image ads at 1.1% CTR and $41.67 CPL. Yet images dominate spend.

  1. Create 2-3 new video creatives for the Outdoor Kitchen campaign showcasing completed projects and customer testimonials.
  2. Shift 30-40% of the Outdoor Kitchen budget ($1,200-1,600) to video ad sets.
  3. Test short-form (15s) vs mid-form (30-45s) to find the optimal length for lead gen.
Est. Impact: Reducing blended CPL from $41 to $30 = 20+ additional leads/month at same spend
9

Add Negative Keywords from Search Term Waste Optimization

Problem: 200 search terms analyzed, many with spend and zero conversions. 73 keywords had zero impressions in 30 days.

  1. Review search terms with $10+ spend and 0 conversions — add irrelevant terms as exact match negatives.
  2. Create shared negative keyword lists for common exclusions (DIY, jobs, courses, suppliers, wholesale).
  3. Pause or remove the 73 zero-impression keywords — they add clutter and don't serve the account.
  4. Set a weekly cadence for search term review (every Monday, 15 minutes).
Est. Impact: 5-10% reduction in wasted spend (~$80-165/month)
10

Test Instant Forms on Meta Experiment

Problem: With 87.7% bounce rate on Paid Social traffic, the website funnel is losing the vast majority of clicks before they convert.

  1. Create a duplicate of the top-performing Outdoor Kitchen Broad campaign using Instant Form instead of Website as the conversion location.
  2. Design the Instant Form with: intro paragraph about outdoor kitchens, 3-4 qualifying questions (budget range, timeline, property type), and auto-fill contact details.
  3. Add a higher-intent qualifying question (e.g., "When are you looking to start?") to maintain lead quality.
  4. Run as A/B test for 2 weeks with 50/50 budget split, then compare CPL and lead quality.
Est. Impact: Instant Forms typically deliver 30-50% lower CPL than website landing pages for lead gen
Report Methodology

Data Period: 11 January – 9 February 2026 (30 days)

Data Sources:

  • Google Ads API (GAQL) — campaigns, keywords, search terms, ads, assets, devices, geo, budgets, conversion actions, landing pages, impression share, hourly/daily trends
  • Meta Graph API — campaigns, ad sets, ads/creative, placements, demographics, daily trends, device breakdown
  • Google Analytics 4 Data API — channel performance, landing page quality, session trends, bounce rates, engagement rates

Scoring: 12 categories scored 1-10 against industry benchmarks for kitchen renovation / home improvement.

Scoring legend:

  • 7-10 — Healthy, performing well
  • 5-6 — Needs attention, room for improvement
  • 1-4 — Critical, requires immediate action

Report features modelled on: Optmyzr Account Audit, Adalysis 100+ Checks, WordStream Performance Grader, SEMrush Advertising Research, TrueClicks Monitoring, GA4 Website Analytics